When Great Sucks: Why You Should Value Low-Hanging Fruit

Photo by H A M A N N on Unsplash

Photo by H A M A N N on Unsplash

Perhaps the second greatest idea-killer after, “It’s already been done,” is “That’s low-hanging fruit.”

The phrase, often used with disdain by creative directors when judging work, implies that the strategy, concept, tactic or deck you’ve just presented is within reach of amateurs, requires little effort to produce, and thus isn’t great enought to be worth considering.

All professional creative people, be they writers, art directors, designers or technologists, are trained to go for what’s new and unusual. We’re supposed to challenge ourselves to climb beyond the easy ideas our mothers (and well-meaning account people) point out to us, go out on a limb, and pluck the perfect produce that lies beyond.

All well and good, if everybody’s aligned on procuring award-winning produce.

But what if the people paying you to climb idea trees don’t want a $1,000,000 apple? What if they want fruit at scale because they’re in the business of making pies? And the most efficient way to deliver isn’t to spend days climbing trees but to give one a rigorous shake and catch whatever falls out?

Too often creatives and even some agencies fail because they spend far too much time trying to get the golden fruit way out on some slender branch, only to fall flat on their face at the pitch meeting because their ideas aren’t ripe enough for public consumption or worse: they’re rotten to the core.

Meanwhile, we ignore the bounty beneath us and let someone else use it to satiate our customers. So that the next time our customers are hungry, it’s someone else that gets asked:

“Got anything great?”

Madison Avenue's Terrifying Truth

I've been thinking a bit about Howard Gossage and the reasons I wanted to make ads in the first place.

And why some people hate what we make so much.

The common criticism is that we're all liars, but if all advertising was false then our work wouldn't resonate.

The problem isn't that great ads aren't 'true' on some important level...

It's that the solutions offered (e.g. buy a better perfume) aren't sufficient to achieve the aspirations presented (fulfilling relationships).

More than A.I., this will be the biggest problem facing our industry going forward.

11 Rules of Undertaking New Projects

I just finished my first freelance business proposal. It took longer than expected but I learned a lot. Here are 11 things:

  1. Always start as early as possible.
  2. Don’t just google “How to ____”, google “Samples of ______”
  3. Structure first.
  4. Never be afraid to be more clear.
  5. It can always be simpler.
  6. Don’t get caught in the trap of what things should look or sound like. If most businesses fail, then why be like most businesses?
  7. Learn from past successes (and failures), but don’t be afraid to try improving.
  8. Get a really good editor and partner.
  9. Everything you write should speak to your target.
  10. The more you set money aside and focus on why they need your help and why you want to help, the more convincing you will be.
  11. Every plan has weaknesses, make sure to address yours.

Let me know if you'd like more or have any to share below.

How to Keep the 2016 Election From Happening Again Part 1

 

Trump won. Protesting isn’t going to change that fact. And neither side is going to forget that this was one of the ugliest and most surprising elections in memory. So what do we do?

We can go on doing the things we’ve done that only soothes our regret or indulges our ids, or we can learn. And I’m speaking to both sides here. Beating up colored people won’t improve your circumstances anymore than occupying Wall Street will, but learning how not to be manipulated by messages crafted to deceive and mislead might. And they were crafted. On both sides.

Trump may be a bully, but he’s not an idiot. This election just proved that he’s more persuasive than Mark Cuban, Robert Cialdini, Hollywood, MSNBC and Hillary Clinton combined. So the first order of business is to learn what Jedi mind tricks he used to get here.

Remember: magic loses its power once you learn how it works. The glass sheet just under the surface makes the walk on water less miraculous.

It won’t be easy, in fact it actually takes more energy to be objective than subjective. But it will help you avoid days like Wednesday, when you were either harassed because you voted for Trump or harassed because you looked like someone who’d vote for Hillary.

I’m an ad guy, and I’m obsessed with persuasion and behavioral psychology. In the next few days/weeks, I’m going to break down some of the ways both candidates manipulated you. And then we’re going to look at what we can do to keep that from happening by thinking like Sherlock Holmes. Finally, we’ll learn how to fight back.

So if you’re interested, stay tuned.